|
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
Introduction
The appraisal of Ambulatory CystoMetry (ACM) as a diagnostic instrument is increasing.
Especially when conventional urodynamics fail to reproduce or explain LUTS and
for the assessment of therapeutic modalities [1]. Several filling and voiding
phases are registered during a period of 6 to 8 hours under circumstances bringing
about the specific conditions causing the individual complaints. Major problems
in the old situation were: only the analyst judged quality of the ACM-investigation
retrospectively. Furthermore, the design of the diary could be improved and
the discrimination between filling and voiding phases was not always evident.
Aim of the study
The aim of this study is to investigate the advantages of introducing a new
quality algorithm to improve and assure the quality of ACM.
Methods
Redesign and validation of the algorithm are based on a method called improvement
management of design processes in a clinical environment [2]. The most important
advantages of this method are elimination of sources of variation, the introduction
of structural feedback during or after every six steps of ACM, using standardised
failure codes by both the operator and the analyst. Based on data of 1204 ACM
investigations in women (mean age 47.0, std. 22.3) and 432 in men (mean age
30.8, std. 15.0) between 1989 and 1997, a new quality algorithm was designed,
implemented and validated. The result was tested in 264 ACM investigations in
women (mean age 51.5, std. 9.2) and 2 in men (mean age 52.9) between 1998 and
2000. The effects of the new algorithm were assessed by comparing the distribution
of quality indices before and after the introduction. Quality indices: 5= event-button
used correctly, duration investigation longer than five hours, transducers in
right position, valid for research purposes, no technical failures; 4= as 5,
but urethral transducers not in right position, some problems with interpretation
due to the catheters; 3= as 4, but event-button used partly incorrect but registration
can still be used for research purposes; 2= as 3 but; unsuitable for research
purposes, some clinical value; 1= no interpretable value; 0= no data. Moreover,
effect were assessed by comparing the inter-observer agreement (ICCA) of the
analysis outcome with respect to bladder overactivity (Detrusor Activity Index,
[3]).
Results
Pressing the event-button twice to mark begin and end of the voiding phases
and the introduction of 52 standardized failure codes are the most important
improvements incorporated in the new algorithm. Failure codes refer to four
phases of ACM: i.e. preparation of the investigation, instruction of the patient,
installation of the equipment and assurance of signal quality, ending the investigation
with signal consistency check. Figure 1 shows the distribution of quality indices
(0 = failed, 5= excellent quality) before and after introduction of the new
quality algorithm. There is an evident quality improvement of 18% (p<0.001)
in ACM's with research quality. The theoretical ICCA before introduction of
the algorithm for one observer was 0.73 (n= 60, raters=4) and after introduction
0.96 (n=111, raters=2).

Figure 1 Improvement of quality distribution ACM
Conclusions
In this study the design of a quality algorithm is presented. Presently, the
quality algorithm is part of the quality system of the urodynamic laboratory.
Due to this project, the quality of the entire ACM-investigation has improved
noticeably and measurably. The designed quality algorithm has been nominated
for a quality award in our hospital. Our methodology is applicable in many forms
of clinical research. References 1. Neurology and Urodynamics, 19:113-125(2000)
2. Kwaliteit in Ambulante Cystometrie, van kwaliteitsbeoordeling naar kwaliteitssysteem,
februari 2000, Eindhoven University of Technology, Stan Ackermans Institute,
NVKF, azM. 3. BJU International (1999) 83, Suppl. 2,16-21 4. The design and
analysis of clinical experiments, 1986 New York ABSTRACT FORM A-2 Office use
only