|

|
FACTORS INFLUENCING
SUCCESS WITH EXTRACORPOREAL MAGNETIC INNERVATION (ExMI) TREATMENT
OF MIXED URINARY INCONTINENCE
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|

|
Authors:
|

|
P. Sand, R. Appell, T.
Bavendam, K. Whitmore, S. Carlan, N. Galloway
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|

|
Institution:
|

|
Evanston Continence Center,
Evanston, IL, USA
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Aims of
Study:
Determine a population most likely to respond to extracorporeal magnetic innervation.
Methods:
This was a prospective outcomes study of extracorporeal magnetic innervation
treatment in women with stress and urge incontinence. Secondary analysis of
the data was performed to identify risk factors, which might predict treatment
failure. Seventy-six women were enrolled in a 6 month prospective outcomes trial
of twice weekly extracorporeal magnetic therapy for 6 weeks, with each treatment
consisting of 10 minutes at 5 Hertz and 10 minutes at 50 Hertz. Subjects were
evaluated at baseline with a 3 day voiding diary, pad weight test, urodynamic
testing, perineometry, and quality of life questionnaires at 8 and 24 weeks
(18 weeks after therapy). Initial analysis revealed 4 primary risk factors which
were analyzed for their impact on short and long-term continence. These were
selected from a group of 67 covariants from the history, vital signs, urodynamic
data, pelvic exam, and perineometry. Statistical evaluation was performed using
Stat Graphics with one-way ANOVA with a Duncan's test. The changes in outcomes
data at 8 and 14 weeks were evaluated using t-tests and one-way ANOVA, respectively.
Results:
Seventy-six women were evaluated at 8 weeks (2 weeks after stimulation) and
58 women at 24 weeks. These 76 women had a mean age of 55.9 years (range 36-83
years). Subjects had been incontinent for an average of 10.7 years (range 1-40
years). Forty-two women (55%) had undergone prior hysterectomy. Twelve (16%)
had prior anti-incontinence surgeries. Seven (9%) were taking medications that
could cause incontinence. Incontinence episodes on voiding diaries at 8 and
24 weeks were ranked as worse than baseline, <25% improved, 25-50% improved,
51-75% improved, 76-99% improved and 100% improved. These outcomes were compared
against risk factors of prior hysterectomy, prior anti-incontinence operations,
incontinence >10 years, and use of medications that could cause incontinence.
At 8 weeks, 13 (17%) had more incontinence episodes on 3-day voiding diary than
at baseline. Seventeen (22%) were <50% improved and 46(61%) were >50% improved
or cured. Twenty-five (33%) were cured (no leakage). Fifty-eight women were
analysed at 24 weeks. Of these, 13 (22%) had worsening of incontinence on voiding
diaries. Nineteen subjects (33%) were <50% improved and 26 (45%) were >50% improved.
Seventeen (29%) were free of leakage (cured) at 24 weeks. The average number
of daily leakage episodes on the 3 day diaries improved from a baseline of 3.5
(S.D. 3.0) to 1.9 (S.D. 2.7) at 8 weeks (p=0.0003). Daily leakage episodes improved
from 3.0 (S.D.2.3) to 2.2 (S.D.2.9) at 24 weeks (p=0.04). Pad weight testing
revealed no significant change from baseline [0.7g (S.D. 1.1)] to 8 weeks [0.5g
(S.D. 1.0)] (p=0.12), nor in the long-term group from baseline [0.7g (S.D. 1.0)]
to 24 weeks [0.6g (S.D. 1.1), p=0.04]. The short term and long term populations
were divided into two subgroups whom did or did not have >50% improvement in
daily leakage from baseline on the voiding diary. These subgroups were analyzed
for impact of the 4 risk factors. The populations with medications that could
cause incontinence and those with prior anti-incontinence operations were too
small for valid analysis. Four of 16 (25%) with prior hysterectomy were completely
dry on voiding diary at 8 weeks and 12 (75%) were improved by >50%. Prior hysterectomy
was significantly related to improvement on voiding diary at 8 weeks (p=0.0005).
This association of hysterectomy and improvement was not noted in the long-term
group (4 of the 11 subjects were improved by >50%). Incontinence >10 years was
found in both the short term (p=0.01) and long term group (p=0.004) to be associated
with >50% reduction in leakage on voiding diaries. Eight of the 18 (44%) short-term
subjects and 6 of the 14 (43%) long-term subjects were cured. Twelve (67%) of
the short-term group and 7 (50%) of the long term group were improved by >50%.
Sixteen subjects in the short-term group and 14 in the long-term group had none
of the 4 risk factors. This group had the best response with 11 (69%) of the
short-term group >50% improved (p=0.00004) and 7 (44%) completely dry. In the
long-term group without risk factors, 8 (57%) had >50% improvement (p=0.005)
and 6 (43%) were completely dry.
Conclusion:
Extracorporeal magnetic innervation was found to be an effective therapy as
measured by voiding diary at 2 weeks and 18 weeks after therapy. This long-term
response without continued treatment is not seen after physiotherapy or pelvic
floor electrical stimulation. Analysis of risk factors suggests that patients
without risk factors respond best with cure rates of 44% and 43% at 8 and 24
weeks, respectively. However, even women with prior hysterectomy or long standing
incontinence do well.